Easy Farmhouse Cheddar Recipe: Cheese At Home The Farmhouse Way (2024)

You may think that it’s very hard to make your own cheese at home, but there are actually quite a few cheese recipes that are very easy. Cheese making has been always an important part of traditional farm cooking. In this article, we will review the many good reasons you should take up cheese making at home. We also share a quick and easy farmhouse cheddar recipe. Read on to learn more.

What You'll Learn Today

  • Why Make Your Own Cheese?
  • Where Do You Start?
  • Easy Farmhouse Cheddar Recipe
    • What You’ll Need
    • Here’s What You’ll Do {10 Steps}
      • Cheese Making In The Early 19th Century

Why Make Your Own Cheese?

Easy Farmhouse Cheddar Recipe: Cheese At Home The Farmhouse Way (1)

Making cheese is a rare skill these days but it doesn’t have to be. It’s actually quite simple to make your own cheese, and when you do you’ll have quite a feather to put in your cap. Homemade cheese is always the perfect thing to bring along to potlucks, picnics and parties.

When you make cheese at home, you can always be certain that it’s made with the very best ingredients. Cheese that you purchase in the store is sure to have a number of additives to enhance its longevity, color and/or texture.

Cheese you make it home will have only what you put in it. You will have complete control over the quality of the ingredients you use. If you want all natural, organic, GMO free cheese, you can make just that.

Cheese making gives you an opportunity to not only learn a new hobby but also to learn about where your food comes from.

If you’re lucky enough to live in a farming community, you may be able to strike up a relationship with a local dairy farmer and to know not only the location of your source of milk, but also her name.

Your kids can help you make cheese. It’s an easy safe kitchen activity that teaches responsibility, chemistry and a bit of math. Once your kids have helped you a time or two, they may be happy to receive cheese starter kits as gifts on birthdays and holidays.

Even poorly made cheese is usually very tasty. As you get started, you may not make perfect cheese, but even if the texture seems all wrong, go ahead and drain it and salt it and give it a try. It may be quite delicious! If you can’t eat it as is, you can always use it in cooking.

Practice makes perfect, and the more you try the better you’ll get.

Where Do You Start?

Easy Farmhouse Cheddar Recipe: Cheese At Home The Farmhouse Way (2)

The steps to making all sorts of cheese are fairly similar and fairly easy. Once you’ve learned the basics, you can branch out and make soft cheese, crumbling cheese, hard cheese and more.

When you make your own cheese, you have the best quality product for the lowest price. Start-up with cheese making is inexpensive, and you may already have some of what you need in your kitchen.

Basically, you’ll need a cooking thermometer, a large pot, some clean cheesecloth and a cheese culture.

Here’s a simple recipe to get you started.

Easy Farmhouse Cheddar Recipe

What You’ll Need

To make two pounds of fresh cheddar, you’ll need:

  • Two gallons of whole milk. You can use cow’s milk or goat’s milk from the store or raw.
  • One packet of direct-set mesophilic starter. Alternately, you can use four ounces of prepared mesophilic starter.
  • Dilute half a teaspoonful of liquid rennet (i.e. half a rennet tablet) in a quarter cup of cool, chlorine-free water.
  • One tablespoonful of cheese salt.
  • Cheese wax or olive oil.

Here’s What You’ll Do {10 Steps}

1. Depending on the type of milk you have, heat it to either 85°F (goat’s milk) or 90°F (cow’s milk). Gradually stir in the starter. Put the lid on the pot and let the milk and starter rest for approximately forty-five minutes.

2. Stir in the diluted rennet using a gentle up-and-down motion. Continue stirring for approximately a minute. Take great care if the milk you are using is fresh, whole cow’s milk. Stir constantly for a full minute with the bottom side of the ladle submerged by about half an inch. This technique will ensure that any risen butterfat gets stirred into the mixture thoroughly.

Put the lid on the pot and keep the mixture consistently warm for forty-five minutes. As above, 85°F is ideal if you’re using goat’s milk, and 90°F is ideal if you’re using cow’s milk. When enough time has elapsed, the curd will break clean.

3. Using a long, sharp knife slice through the curd in a criss-cross pattern about half an inch apart. The end result will be a cubed pattern on the top. See the video below for a demonstration.

4. Put the pot into another large pot filled with hot water. Increase the heat under the pot gradually until the curds’ temperature measures 100°F. This entire process should take about half an hour. The temperature should not rise by more than a couple of degrees every five minutes.

Throughout this process, stir through the curds gently to prevent them from becoming matted. As the curds heat up, they will become smaller. As this happens, the amount of whey (liquid) will increase.

5. Remove the container from the heat, put the lid on and allow it to sit for five minutes. Line a colander with cheesecloth. When the five minutes are up, pour the curds and whey through the cheesecloth. Retain the whey because you can use it in place of milk or other liquids in baked goods. The result is a very light and flavorful product.

6. Tie up the corners of the cheesecloth to create a bag. Hang this bag up in a warm area that is free of drafts. Let the whey drain for an hour.

Put the drained curds into a large bowl and break them into pieces with your fingertips. Add salt.

7. Line a mold with cheesecloth and press the curds into it. Fold the cheesecloth neatly over the top of the curds. Put a 10 pound weight on top of this for ten minutes.

8. After ten minutes, tip the cheese out of the mold and peel the cheesecloth away. Turn the cheese over, wrap it in fresh cheesecloth, put it back in the mold and put 20 pounds of weight on it for another ten minutes. Do this again, but finish up with 50 pounds of weight left in place for twelve hours.

9. Tip the cheese out of the mold, peel off the cheesecloth and allow the cheese to air dry at room temperature until it has developed a rind and the surface is completely dry.

This process may take between two and four days. If the weather is dry, the time will be shorter. Humid weather will cause a longer waiting time. Throughout this process, turn the cheese several times daily so that it will dry evenly all over.

10. At this point, you can coat the cheese with wax, or you can rub it all over with olive oil for protection. Allow the cheese to age for a month in a warm, dry, draft free setting. Turn the cheese daily to ensure that it dries and ages evenly.

There are so many uses for cheddar in your kitchen. I love to add a bit into my homemade farmhouse soup.

Cheese Making In The Early 19th Century

Looking for more food inspirations? Here is our guide to cooking carp on a farm grill, or even a farm raised alligator.

Easy Farmhouse Cheddar Recipe: Cheese At Home The Farmhouse Way (2024)


What is the difference between cheddar and farmhouse cheddar? ›

Farmhouse Cheddar is a more rustic version of traditional Cheddar and is made with the exclusion of the traditional cheddaring process of stacking and milling. Farmhouse cheddar tends to be slightly drier and crumblier than traditional Cheddar but still has a full and sharp flavour.

Which cheese is easiest to make? ›

Make chèvre. It is the world's easiest cheese. Or, if you do not have access to goat's milk, make fromage blanc. The process is just the same, and the results are just as impressive.

How do you make cheese without culture? ›

Sometimes cheese is made without using cheese cultures and instead alternative food acids are used such as: citric acid, vinegar, lemon juice and tartaric acid. With these acid options, you'll end up making soft cheeses like paneer, Queso Blanco, mozzarella or mascarpone.

Is it cheaper to make your own cheddar cheese? ›

Rich, aged, and high-quality cheeses often come with a higher sticker price attached because of the duration it takes to make them. However, if you opt in to make your own cheese, the overall costs will save you a ton down the line!

What does West Country Farmhouse Cheddar taste like? ›

West Country Farmhouse Production Cheddar is a typical English-slightly sharp but with a rich and dense flavour of pasture and onions. Aged in a cloth before adding the wax covering. The cloth that binds this traditional, hand-made Dorset Cheddar allows the cheese to 'breathe' as it matures in the Wookey Hole caves.

What is the hardest cheese to make? ›

While there is no one type of difficult cheese to make, the hardest cheeses to make are romano, gorgonzola, burrata, parmesan, provolone, etc. The reason being is because they require a longer aging period to ensure they reach their desired texture and require a specific type of culture.

Can I make good cheese at home? ›

Making cheese at home is incredibly easy and requires only a few ingredients and no specialized equipment, just a sauce pan, colander, and some cheese cloth. Turns out, subtle variations on a pretty basic theme produce all kinds of wonderful homemade cheeses.

Can you make cheese without starter? ›

Cheeses made without added starter culture encompass traditional rennet coagulated cheeses that rely on natural milk microbiota to achieve the fermentation of lactose to lactic acid.

Can you make cheddar cheese without mesophilic culture? ›

mesophilic cultures is essential for many types of fresh, young and medium aged cheese including Cheddar, Gouda and Chèvre as well as washed and bloomy rind cheese including Muenster and Camembert.

Why is shredding your own cheese better? ›

Pre-grated cheese contains preservatives like potato starch and natamycin, meant to keep the shreds from clumping together in the bag. That means the cheese won't melt well when used for cooking. Freshly grated cheese does not contain those additives, so your recipes will turn out less clumpy and much smoother.

What brings out the flavor of cheese? ›

Cheese flavor is influenced by many factors including milk source, milk thermal treatment, type and dose of lactic starter culture, process conditions, and time and temperature of ripening.

What are the three types of cheddar? ›

What are the different types of cheddar cheese? Cheddar cheese comes in mild, sharp, and extra sharp varieties. Mild cheddars are aged from 3 to 6 months, while sharp cheddars are aged 9 to 12 months. Extra sharp cheddars are generally aged up to two years, though some cheddars are aged as long as 10 years or more.

What are the 2 types of cheddar? ›

Types of Cheddar

Mild cheddar is young and smooth, with a subtle, buttery taste. Medium cheddar has a slightly stronger flavor, while sharp cheddar has a tangy and robust taste that pairs well with bold flavors.

What is the difference between types of cheddar? ›

The longer a cheese is aged, the more pronounced and sharp its flavor. This is what distinguishes mild cheddar (typically aged for just a couple months, with a smooth, not too distinct taste) from more flavorful, pronounced sharp cheddar (aged up to a year or longer). One type of aged cheddar we love is Alpine.

What are the different types of cheddar cheese? ›

It is sold in several varieties, namely mild, medium, sharp, extra sharp, New York style, white, and Vermont. New York–style cheddar is particularly sharp/acidic, but tends to be somewhat softer than the milder-tasting varieties.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 6556

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1997-03-23

Address: 74183 Thomas Course, Port Micheal, OK 55446-1529

Phone: +13408645881558

Job: Global Representative

Hobby: Sailing, Vehicle restoration, Rowing, Ghost hunting, Scrapbooking, Rugby, Board sports

Introduction: My name is Geoffrey Lueilwitz, I am a zealous, encouraging, sparkling, enchanting, graceful, faithful, nice person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.